Short sale and deed-in-lieu explained: Both are foreclosure alternatives for underwater homeowners who owe more than their home’s value. A short sale lets you sell the home for less than owed with lender approval, while a deed-in-lieu involves handing the home back to the lender. This guide compares both options to help homeowners, investors, and professionals choose the best path to avoid foreclosure and reduce financial damage.
What Does It Mean to Be an “Underwater Homeowner”?
An underwater mortgage—also known as negative equity—occurs when the amount you owe on your home loan exceeds your property’s current market value.
Example:
- Mortgage balance: $340,000
- Home value: $290,000
- Negative equity: $50,000
This can happen due to:
- Falling property values
- Overleveraged borrowing
- Economic downturns
- Emergency refinancing or second mortgages
If selling the home wouldn’t pay off your mortgage, you’re “underwater.” This is where short sales and deeds-in-lieu of foreclosure come into play.
Option 1: What Is a Short Sale?
A short sale is when your mortgage lender allows you to sell your home for less than you owe on the loan. The lender agrees to accept the shortfall as payment in full (or negotiates a repayment plan).
Real Example:
- You owe $300,000
- Home’s fair market value: $270,000
- Buyer offers: $270,000
- Lender approves sale and forgives the $30,000 deficit
Benefits of a Short Sale:
- Avoids foreclosure—less damage to your credit report
- You can stay in the home during the process
- Often includes relocation assistance
- May qualify for future home purchase sooner (in as little as 2 years)
- Could receive full or partial forgiveness of the unpaid mortgage balance
Drawbacks:
- Requires lender approval for both the shortfall and sale
- May take 3–6 months or more to finalize
- Requires a willing buyer and active market listings
- Potential tax implications (forgiven debt may be considered income)
- Credit score may drop by 100–150 points
Option 2: What Is a Deed-in-Lieu of Foreclosure?
A deed-in-lieu allows you to voluntarily transfer ownership of your home to the lender, avoiding the formal foreclosure process. Essentially, you hand over the deed in exchange for potential forgiveness of your mortgage debt.
Real Example:
- You owe $280,000
- Home’s fair market value: $250,000
- You sign the deed over to the lender and walk away
- The lender may forgive the $30,000 difference and possibly offer moving expenses
Benefits of a Deed-in-Lieu:
- Faster process—usually resolved in 30–90 days
- May include relocation/moving assistance
- Less damaging to credit than foreclosure
- Avoids court proceedings and public foreclosure
Drawbacks:
- You must vacate the home quickly
- Often not available if there are multiple mortgages or liens
- Lender may require proof that the property was unsuccessfully marketed first
- May have tax consequences
- Still appears on your credit report for up to 7 years
Side-by-Side Comparison: Short Sale vs. Deed-in-Lieu
| Criteria | Short Sale | Deed-in-Lieu of Foreclosure |
| Home sold to | Third-party buyer | Mortgage lender |
| Requires lender approval | Yes | Yes |
| Time to complete | 3–6 months or more | 30–90 days |
| Credit score impact | Moderate (100–150 points) | Moderate to high (up to 150 points) |
| Stays in home temporarily? | Yes | No |
| May qualify to buy again in | 2–4 years | 4–7 years |
| Best if… | You can market/sell your home | You can’t sell and want faster closure |
Let’s Run the Numbers: Which Saves More?
Scenario:
- Mortgage balance: $350,000
- Home value: $300,000
- Monthly mortgage: $2,100
- You’re 4 months behind on payments
Short Sale Outcome:
- Sale price: $300,000
- Lender forgives $50,000
- You avoid foreclosure
- Credit recovery starts within 2–3 years
- You qualify for a conventional loan in 4 years
Deed-in-Lieu Outcome:
- You hand over the deed
- Lender forgives $50,000
- You receive $3,000 in relocation assistance
- Credit recovery starts after 4–5 years
- You may rent for 5–7 years before buying again
Key Questions to Ask Yourself
1. Can I sell my home quickly and at a competitive price?
- ✔️ Yes → Short sale may be best
- ❌ No → Consider deed-in-lieu
2. Do I have multiple loans or liens on the property?
- ✔️ Yes → Short sale is often more viable
- ❌ No → Either may work
3. Do I need to buy another home soon?
- ✔️ Yes → Short sale gives a quicker path to requalification
- ❌ No → Deed-in-lieu may be faster for walking away
4. How soon do I need to move out?
- Want more time? → Choose short sale
- Ready to leave ASAP? → Deed-in-lieu might be faster
Tips for a Smooth Process
- ✅ Talk to your lender early—don’t wait until you’re too far behind
- ✅ Hire a real estate agent who specializes in distressed properties
- ✅ Keep records of all communications and documentation
- ✅ Ask about relocation assistance or deficiency waivers
- ✅ Consult a tax professional about potential tax liabilities
- ✅ Work with a HUD-approved housing counselor for free guidance
Find a local HUD counselor: https://www.hud.gov/counseling
Tools & Resources to Help You Decide
- Loan-to-Value Calculator
Use Bankrate’s LTV Calculator - Short Sale Checklist
Download here (internal resource link) - Read next: How to Avoid Foreclosure Without Ruining Your Credit
Explore article
Final Thoughts:
Both short sales and deeds-in-lieu are better alternatives than foreclosure. But the best choice depends on your personal goals, financial hardship, and how long you can stay in the home.